19 November 2026

When Your Team Has More Work Than Capacity

By

Kate Waterfall Hill

Your team says they're drowning. You look at the numbers and wonder what everyone's doing all day.

Does this sound familiar? It's one of the trickiest conversations in leadership. Your team insists they can't take on another thing. You're looking at tight margins, increasing costs and a business that somehow managed the same workload six months ago.

So who's right? Possibly both of you.

A team can look busy and be badly organised. They can look perfectly calm and be completely overloaded. And a business can keep delivering everything it promised while quietly storing up problems that will eventually come back to bite.

The mistake is turning it into an argument about who's working hard enough, rather than understanding what's actually happening.

Before you decide whether you need more people, you need to understand what's eating up the capacity you've already got.

If you'd prefer to listen, this topic is also discussed in Episode 82 of the How to Lead podcast.

Is it a volume problem?

Sometimes there is simply more work than the available people can reasonably do. That sounds obvious, but businesses can spend months avoiding the conclusion because recruiting someone costs money.

Look at what has actually changed. Have you won more clients? Are people managing more accounts or projects than they used to? Has the team shrunk without the workload shrinking with it? Are there more channels, more reporting requirements, more stakeholders or more deliverables?

Jobs have a habit of getting bigger, without us noticing. An account manager who used to manage the client may now also be managing the project plan, the budget tracker, Teams messages, reporting dashboards, workflow tools, internal stakeholders and goodness knows how much other administration surrounding the actual work. 

Technology has made some things quicker. It has also given us an extraordinary number of new ways to create work for each other.

I’d be very wary of judging this from visible activity. Linda’s evidence that her team has spare capacity is that somebody was laughing. I’ve also heard leaders point out that everyone left at 5:30, as if five minutes of human behaviour disproves six months of pressure. 

People need thinking time, relationship time and recovery time. And occasionally a conversation about Love Island.

The question isn’t whether everybody looks frantically busy every minute of the day. It’s whether the team can deliver the required work, to the required standard, sustainably.

You can run above sensible capacity for quite a long time. People work later, managers pick things up themselves, quality control gets squeezed and proactive work disappears. Everyone becomes very efficient at firefighting, and on paper you’re coping. 

Until somebody leaves, or you lose a client, or mistakes start appearing. Or your managers are so busy doing the work that they have no time to manage anybody. Suddenly, your entire management team is stuck in the engine room, keeping things running rather than actually leading.

Is it a friction problem?

This is the bit teams don’t always want to hear. Sometimes you don’t need another person. You need to stop wasting the time of the people you already have.

I’ve gone into organisations where everyone is convinced they need more resources, and when you look properly at how the work moves through the business, it’s painful. There are meetings that don’t need to happen. Three people approve something one person could approve. Senior people sit on decisions for days. Poor briefs create endless rework. People do manually what could easily be automated. Nobody is quite sure who owns what. The same conversation happens in Teams, then in email, then again in a meeting. Work gets redone because somebody important wandered in at the end and changed their mind.

And yes, clients ask for things that weren’t in the original brief. I covered scope creep in the previous blog, because it deserves proper attention in its own right, but it matters here too. Uncontrolled extra work is one way a team that should theoretically have enough capacity suddenly doesn’t.

The important thing is not to assume every capacity problem needs more headcount. If you put another person into a system full of bottlenecks, unnecessary work and endless rework, you’ve just made the broken system more expensive.

So before hiring, follow the work. Where does it get stuck? Where does it come back? Where are people waiting, or duplicating effort? What exists only because “we’ve always done it”? You can often create meaningful capacity without asking anybody to work faster.

Is it a prioritisation problem?

This is probably the one I see most often. Everything is important, everything is urgent, every client matters, every internal initiative must continue, and every request from someone senior gets added to the list. Nobody ever removes anything. Eventually you have 14 priorities, which is another way of saying you have none.

Leaders have to make choices. If you ask someone to take on something new, one of the most useful questions you can ask is, “What should move to make room for this?” It’s a very different question from “Can you squeeze this in?”, because people will squeeze things in, especially your conscientious ones. They’ll work through lunch, stay late, do it at home, lower the standard somewhere else, stop coaching their team, or put off something that has no immediate deadline.

I’m not immune to this either. I’ve handed someone “one small thing” without asking what it was displacing, and been pleased when it appeared to cost nothing. It had cost something. I just couldn’t see it.

The organisation then never sees the true cost of the additional work. Your best people can disguise a capacity problem for an astonishingly long time. That doesn’t mean it isn’t there. It means they’re absorbing it personally, and that isn’t a sustainable operating model.

So how do you know when you really need more resource?

Once you’ve looked at volume, friction and prioritisation, you’re in a much better position to answer that.

If you’re the person asking, I’d encourage you not to rely solely on “We’re all really overwhelmed.” It may be completely true, but the person approving another salary needs more than that. Show them what is happening. Each account manager is running eight projects at once instead of five. Review time has dropped, and errors are rising. You’re missing proactive client opportunities because all your available capacity is reactive. Or you’ve removed some meetings, streamlined a process, and changed a workflow, and you still have a defined number of hours of work against fewer available hours. Now you have a commercial case. It's also considerably more persuasive than an email about pulling together.

I’d also bring options rather than one solution. You may need another permanent person. But could you use a freelancer while you test whether the workload is sustained? Could you change the timing, stop doing something, automate some admin or move work between roles? Could you increase prices, change the service level or lose an unprofitable client? The point is to solve the capacity problem, not to decide in advance that the solution is another employee.

If you’re the leader resisting additional resource, apply the same standard to yourself. “We can’t afford another person” needs to be set against what the current situation is costing you. What is the cost of mistakes, of staff turnover, of senior people doing junior work because nobody else has capacity? What about lost clients, missed opportunities, poor quality, and managers who spend the whole week delivering rather than managing? Sometimes not hiring is absolutely the right commercial decision. Sometimes it’s an expensive decision disguised as a saving.

And watch out for “temporarily”

Most businesses have peaks. A pitch comes in, three projects land at once, somebody is off sick, a deadline moves. For a few weeks everyone pulls together and does a bit more. That’s business.

The problem comes when temporary pressure becomes the normal operating model. If every month is exceptional, it isn’t exceptional any more. If you’ve been telling people “We just need to get through the next few weeks” since Christmas, stop calling it a busy period and start looking at your operating model. If it’s been going on since 2019, you can stop calling it a season. There’s a big difference between occasionally asking people to stretch and building a business that only works when everybody stretches all the time.

A checklist for the next capacity conversation

If your team keeps telling you they’re at capacity, don’t approve another hire right away. Don’t immediately tell them to be more efficient either. Diagnose it.


  1. Volume: has the amount or complexity of work genuinely increased? Look at projects, clients, deliverables, responsibilities and available hours.

  2. Friction: where is existing capacity being wasted? Look for unnecessary meetings, slow decisions, poor briefs, duplication, rework, excessive amends and cumbersome processes.

  3. Prioritisation: are you making choices about what matters? When something new arrives, what moves, stops or gets done differently?

  4. Sustainability: beyond whether the work is currently getting done, what is it costing you in quality, management time, mistakes, missed opportunities and people?

  5. Options: if there is still a genuine capacity gap, what is the best way to close it? That might be another employee, freelance support, changing the service, stopping something or charging more.

Then make the decision based on evidence rather than whoever argues most loudly in the capacity meeting.

A healthy business isn’t one where nobody ever feels stretched. There will always be busy periods. It’s one where leaders know the difference between a busy week and a broken operating model, and where good people aren’t expected to compensate for that difference indefinitely.

When something new landed on your team last, did anyone ask what should move to make room for it?

Or did everyone just find a way to absorb it?

Leadership isn't about squeezing more and more out of the same people. It's about making decisions, setting priorities and creating the conditions for your team to do their best work.

Sometimes that means having conversations you'd rather avoid.

This is the kind of real-world leadership challenge we tackle inside The Leadership Accelerator. From difficult conversations and competing priorities to building teams that can perform without constantly running on empty.

If you want to stop managing the pressure and start leading differently, explore the Leadership Accelerator here.

Take the free leadership evolution quiz

Take the free leadership evolution quiz

Take the free leadership evolution quiz

© 2026

Kate Waterfall Hill. All rights reserved.

© 2026

Kate Waterfall Hill. All rights reserved.

© 2026

Kate Waterfall Hill. All rights reserved.